In the early ‘s the village of Montaillou & the surrounding mountainous region of Southern France was full of heretics. When Jacquest Fournier, Bishop of. 12 Oct Montaillou: The Promised Land of Error. by Emmanuel Le Roy Ladurie, translated by Barbara Bray. Braziller, pp., $ In the early ‘s the village of Montaillou-and the surrounding mountainous region of Southern France-was full of heretics. When Jacquest Fournier, Bishop of.
|Published (Last):||16 January 2014|
|PDF File Size:||5.69 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||7.58 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
There are special analyses of sexuality and spirituality t This is really quite a lengthy academic work, based on the exceptionally detailed transcriptions of a medieval inquisition in a remote village in the Pyrenees. I see Cantor’s point, but also think that if such records are the only ones available, then why not make use of them?
This is the first time I have heard the word “heretic” used as a compliment! Paperbackpages. This is really quite a lengthy academic work, based on the exceptionally detailed transcriptions of a medieval inquisition in a remote village in the Pyrenees. Unfortunately, the point is made at the cost of most montaillou the promised land of error, because montaillou the promised land of error emotional data points that drive the heroic or romantic a.
Montaillou was much more successful than either Ladurie or his publishers had anticipated, selling more thancopies and being translated into multiple languages. The bestselling portrait of life in a medieval village, which sums it up much better.
Ladurie’s Montaillou is montillou history book in the Annales tradition. Page 1 of 1 Start over Page 1 of 1. Families in various was tried to build up their particular domus, and worked with a view to posterity.
For example, the Cathar heaven in Montaillou was conceived as a giant domus.
He was pitiless in the pursuit of error, and meticulous montailllou recording that pursuit. Montaillou is unusual for its use of a single source, the inquisition register, montai,lou so much of the montailloj. Montaillou the promised land of error was pleased by how well the author managed to balance academic rigor and approachability in the narrative.
He eerror the Inquisition records on which he bases his account to create an almost soap opera like atmosphere. If you care to, you can feel like you’re right there with the beleaguered peasants of Montaillou.
The only quibbles I have are that it is a little to long, and it constructs huge amounts of analysis on a fairly small set of data. Some even say aloud that incest is preferable to letting one of the girls of the family go to another domus and take her dowry with her.
Sex, death and delousing–sounds too good to be true. The book’s fascination and brilliance lies not so much in its discussion of the inquisition but in the insight the inquisition’s depositions that it took from the peasants gives into the lives of the people of Montaillou.
Ladurie also montaillou the promised land of error promlsed interesting contrast between Pierre Maury, for whom fate and fortune “are primarily individual entities, affecting the life of one person,” and Pierre Clergue, for whom “fortune is above all connected with the common fate of his line and his household.
Emmanuel Le Roy Ladurie. May montaillou the promised land of error, Nancy rated it really liked it Shelves: The guy never stopped.
I get the draw of that Cathar stuff – it does at least allow you to have a bit of a laugh while you’re alive. They became ensnared in what must have seemed like an attractive alternative to the parasitic Catholic Church.
These quotations feel, in fact, like a little window to a very montaillou the promised land of error time, one that is difficult to imagine today. The Peasants of Languedoc. My library Help Advanced Book Search.
His reading of the archives is so subtle and insightful that we find family stories and detailed accounts of the lives of the peasant inhabitants montaillou the promised land of error Montaillou, the last village to support the ‘heresy’ and the recipients of special attention form the Inquisition as the church set out to reassert its authority.
Ladurie accords Catharism respect, and the Inquisition is not portrayed in a flattering light. Though Ladurie does not generally romanticize the Montaillou peasants, there is a great exception. Fournier’s Inquisition successfully squashed the Cathar heresy once and for all at its center in the small village of Montaillou. Real life stories, and ones montaillou the promised land of error which you can empathize. Buy the selected items together This item: From Gaufrette Saint-Gilles” “Sorry, cousin.
The book’s fa When I began my undergraduate career I was part of an honors seminar where this was one of the books we read.
MONTAILLOU: The Promised Land of Error by Emmanuel Le Roy Ladurie | Kirkus Reviews
A Church Inquisitor, Jacques Fournier, interrogated the villagers. To ask other readers questions about Montaillouplease sign up. Those who understand what the author is about will probably enjoy this unusual bottom-up view of the 14th century; those who don’t may find the book dull, academic, and overly repetitive.
In short, I was not in montaillou the promised land of error best of moods during much of reading process.
Montaillou: The Promised Land of Error
Life in the French village of Montaillou in the early 14th century is unusually well documented thanks to an assiduous inquisitor. Mmontaillou refreshing to get a glimpse of ordinary folk in this period. This turned into a montaillou the promised land of error I could not put down, which I never would have expected! I adore this book – it is one of the great texts of history from below and a ppromised lesson in use of an archive to read through official records to find the stories of the people.